I found a lollipop made for cats at the pet store. The kind I found was made of freeze-dried chicken pressed into a heart shape on a paper stick.

Thor the cat enjoyed the lollipops the best, he actually licked it, then bit it. When he did bite off a chunk he swallowed it whole, which concerned me because they weren’t small chunks. Izzy the calico was not impressed. Sophie the dilute calico couldn’t be bothered with licking and just chomped hard through the whole lollipop.